Blog Entry

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

Posted on: February 2, 2012 10:53 am
Edited on: February 2, 2012 11:17 am

Posted by Bryan Fischer

It's time to pick up the wrapping paper, survey the damage and get excited to play with your new toys as Signing Day - i.e. Christmas in February for college football coaches and fans - has come to a close. Here's a broad overview of what happened from coast-to-coast.

Houston, we have a five-star

If there was one big - to borrow a metaphor from another sport - curve ball on Signing Day that made everybody scratch their head in disbelief it was word that Fresno (Calif.) wide receiver Deontay Greenberry had surprisingly signed with Houston during the middle of the day. It's normally a bit unusual when a program like UH signs anybody from outside the states of Texas or Louisiana and even more puzzling when they sign a highly rated player. But Greenberry? In addition to becoming the highest-ranked recruit the program has ever inked, the switch was cause for celebration inside the football office for a coup of epic proportions.

In short: Houston stole a five-star recruit on the week before Signing Day from Notre Dame.

This wasn't a local big time kid, this was the state of California's best wide receiver and somebody the Irish were counting on to play early and often with the departure of guys like Michael Floyd. The Cougars were not only closer to a BCS game than the storied program but they picked their pockets for one of their top recruits. It should have been a big day for Brian Kelly to trumpet guys like number two overall player and Columbus (Ind.) quarterback Gunner Kiel or Greenberry's cousin, cornerback Tee Shepard. Instead it was Kelly who was trying to spin the loss during his annual press conference.

"It is hard for me to feel disappointed about something I have never had, or someone I have never coached," Kelly said. "I'm more excited about the 16 who did sign."

The reason the 6-foot-3, 187-pound wide out flipped was primarily due to Houston receivers coach Jamie Christian, who came over from Arizona State. Christian had kept the Sun Devils in the running (Greenberry took a visit in October and considered them as late as December) despite a commitment to Notre Dame until Dennis Erickson's staff was fired and deserves the lion's share of the credit for getting Greenberry on campus last weekend and for ultimately landing a top-ranked guy. Cougars' head coach Tony Levine has developed some very successful wide receivers over the past several years and it appears he's got somebody a lot more talented than he's ever coached coming in with the class of 2012.

One in January, another in February

Texas coach Mack Brown has picked up the title Mr. February due to his penchant for winning a recruiting title but lack of success in translating that into a national title. After the run Nick Saban has had at Alabama recently, it might be time to find something that accurately describes his dominance in the first two months of the year because he's not limited to one or the other. As expected, the Crimson Tide took home the top recruiting class in the country in 2012 but perhaps the only thing that was surprising about it was that it wasn't, well, surprising.

"We knew exactly pretty much what we were gonna get," Saban said. "We didn't really have any surprises."

The only thing that even registered on the meter was when defensive tackle Korren Kirven decided to go away from home and play for the Crimson Tide (part of the reason why a numbers crunch led to some like defensive tackle Darius Philon signing at Arkansas). All told, 28 players will be considered part of yet another recruiting title for a program that seems to land any recruit they want, including an impressive six top 100 players.

The headliner is Geismar (La.) defensive back Landon Collins, who signed sans drama Wednesday and even seems to have patched things up with his mother following the bizarre reaction she had when he committed at the Under Armour All-American Game early last month. A ball-hawk who isn't afraid to lower the shoulder and stick the ball carrier, Collins is bound to find a role early on in the secondary. This class didn't really load up on offensive lineman but filled out just about everywhere else was stacked. The front seven in particular could see plenty of recruits turn into All-Americans, led by the impressive Reggie Ragland and Dillon Lee. Offensively there are some speedsters at wide out and T.J. Yeldon might be the best running back coming into the conference.

The Tide, it appears, just can't stop rolling.


Though the news had broken that the country's top overall player in the class of 2012 would likely be headed to Columbia, nobody was truly sure until the the 6-foot-6 Dorial Green-Beckham put on the Missouri hat and officially sent his LOI in. The announcement seemed a little ho-hum despite the nearly 1,000 people watching locally and the national television audience but that's mainly a testament to the reserved Green-Beckham himself.

With many analysts calling him the second coming of Randy Moss, there's immense pressure on the top-ranked wide receiver and for good reason. There are few prospects as impressive physically as Green-Beckham and though he doesn't have great hands and needs some polish, the underlying natural talent is a good reason why he was highly regarded and highly recruited. Missouri has had success building around taller, bigger pass catchers in their offense and it looks like they'll have three years to see what kind of eye popping numbers

It can't be understated how big this is for a program like Mizzou. Landing the top recruit in the country is not just about getting a good player, it's about adding a level of prestige to the program. A talent like DGB only comes along once in a generation and for the Tigers to keep him at home is understandably huge, especially with the move to the SEC. Gary Pinkel has had plenty of success over the past several years even if it hasn't resulted in a championship and everybody understands that the competitions is about to be ratcheted up several notches going forward. With the signature of Green-Beckham, Pinkel and Mizzou proved that even if guys like Mack Brown, Bob Stoops and Nick Saban really want a kid, the Tigers can compete off and - hopefully - on the field in their new league going forward.

Nerd Search 2012

Outside of alumni and those that have to write about the Pac-12, there weren't too many mentions of Stanford on Signing Day every year.

My how times have changed.

Not only did the Cardinal tie for the national lead with six top 100 prospects, but they landed multiple five-stars and had people talking less about Andrew Luck and more about the fact that maybe this program can indeed sustain excellence going forward. There's no denying that it was one of the best years for talent on the West Coast in some time and the big reason why was the number of elite offensive lineman. If this were a few years ago, many of them would be penciled in to go to USC or Oregon or out of the area to programs like Notre Dame but instead it was Stanford who reeled the majority of the elite guys in this year (Josh Garnett, Andrus Peat, Kyle Murphy). If you were to call this the best offensive line class in recent recruiting history, you wouldn't find too many who would argue. That's just how much of a difference the school was this year and the coaches' efforts were rewarded with a top 10 class ranking.

It wasn't just an academic powerhouse like Stanford who made waves either. Northwestern landed a pair of top players in Malin Jones and Ifeadi Odenigbo. Vanderbilt brought in what some called the best class in school history. Duke landed a lightly recruited guy who, according to recruiting coordinator Matt Lubick on the Signing Day Central Show, runs a sub-4.3 40 yard dash. Lots of recruits talk about wanting academics but it appears they're finally following up.

Pocket squares and pads seem to be the latest thing on the recruiting trail.

More recruiting SECcess

It wasn't quite the banner year for the league that it could have been but 2012 certainly was a great Signing Day for the best conference in the country. Eight of the SEC's 14 teams finished in the final top 25 class rankings, highlighted by Alabama at the top and both of the league newcomers turning in great first efforts. Texas A&M ended up stealing defensive tackle Edmund Ray from Missouri and added wide receiver Thomas Johnson, a former Texas commitment, to a group that finished 14th. Florida was a top five class despite missing out on some guys and even a few programs that have recently struggled did well with Georgia, Tennessee and Auburn grouped together from 20-22.

The Bulldogs had to land just about every target left on their board and they did ok, notably beating Florida State late for linebacker Josh Harvey-Clemons despite a little issue with his grandfather not signing his letter of intent until Thursday. The Bulldogs missed out on Juco wide receiver Cordarrelle Patterson (who went to Tennessee) and offensive tackle Avery Young (to Auburn) but also landed five-star offensive lineman John Theus and what might be the best one-two punch at running back in the class with Keith Marshall and Todd Gurley. It wasn't a "Dream Team" but Georgia still showed you can have a very good class and it only be alright in such a deep league.

Kentucky brought in what might be the top quarterback in the state this year in Patrick Towles and took advantage of Alabama's number crunch in grabbing running back Justin Taylor. The state of Georgia was a big producer of talent for a lot of the league's schools and is quickly becoming the go-to state for most FBS programs after the big three of California, Texas and Florida. The theme this year was even if a school didn't pick up a commitment from a kid, there's a high chance he went to another SEC school.

Quality over quantity

This was finally the year that we'd see NCAA sanctions limit USC and Lane Kiffin had to be creative in how he managed the numbers on top of grabbing the best talent available. Even though the Trojans missed out on linemen Peat and Murphy, it was still a good haul with Zach Banner, Jordan Simmons and Max Tuerk on top of skill position talent like five-star Nelson Agholor, linebacker Jabari Ruffin, end Leonard Williams and wide receiver Darreus Rogers. Given the way the staff has recruited over the past two years, it's looking more likely that the school can get through harsh NCAA sanctions better than was previously thought. Missing out on three guys may seem like a lot but it should help next year by giving Kiffin those scholarships to use for early enrollees in 2013.

Meyer Mayhem

FYI to coaches across the country, if Urban Meyer starts circling your recruits, you better be prepared to bring your A+++ game if you want to land them. The master recruiter took Ohio State's class from middling prior to his hire to tying the nation's lead with six top 100 recruits and a number three overall class ranking. This was, mind you, with only two months on the job to recruit with a program that just got slapped with a bowl ban from the NCAA. Meyer really attacked the defensive line and looks like he'll be importing a high quality, SEC-caliber defensive line with Se'Von Pittman, Tommy Schutt, Noah Spence and Adolphus Washington. He's already jumped on several top 2013 players and if this year was any indication, it could be a long couple of years for his Big Ten counterparts.

Seminole DLight

Mark Stoops is the defensive coordinator at Florida State and he might be the happiest man in the state of Florida. As good as Ohio State's defensive line class was, FSU's might be the best in the country. Though they lost Dante Fowler Jr., they still signed Chris Casher, Mario Edwards, Eddie Goldman, Justin Shanks and should get Dalvon Stuckey in a year or two after he goes to a Juco. The thing about the Seminoles is that they don't need every guy to come in and play right away but each is talented enough to make an impact in certain situations. Edwards has the pedigree and drive to become a high first round draft pick with his skill set and Stoops should use him in multiple spots. Adding guys like Ronald Darby and P.J. Williams are also huge gets for the program in the secondary. Whoever plays the best defense likely has a leg up in the ACC and it appears that's where Florida State did the best on Wednesday.

More on Signing Day
Dennis Dodd

Urban strikes gold right away; stigma of Tressel scandal already gone

Brett McMurphy

Forget suspense and excitement, it's just another 'Bama Signing Day
Related links
The Golden Touch

The early indication that things would be going Miami's way came when one of the country's top uncommitted recruits, Miramar (Fla.) cornerback Tracy Howard, flashed the "U" sign on national television and made, to some, the surprising decision to stay home and play for the Hurricanes. Although Howard's recruitment was a bit difficult to read, it appeared there was only a slim chance that he'd leave the state and most were predicting he was Florida's to lose down the stretch.

Much like Stanford this year, there weren't a whole lot of recruits the program missed out on that they were after hard - a remarkable accomplishment given what's swirling around Coral Gables. The loss of linebacker Reggie Northrup hurts because he could play multiple positions and is easily one of the top linebacker prospects in the state. That he switched to archival Florida State stung a little but that was one of the rare occasions were the Hurricanes were slowed down. This was the largest class in the country and plenty of the recruits should see early playing time with guys like Duke Johnson making an impact from the moment they step on campus. Al Golden had to climb a mountain but did a great job grabbing the guys he did.


Not sure any assistant had a greater impact on multiple programs than new Washington coach Tosh Lupoi. California's class imploded, Washington landed the #5 player in the country in Shaq Thompson, UCLA added Jordan Payton and Oregon picked up Arik Armstead due to the uncertainty. One wonders if Lupoi had been hired earlier how much more impact he would have had for the Huskies' class but it's clear he shifted the recruiting trail in the conference in just a few short weeks.

In addition to Washington, USC, Stanford, plenty of other Pac-12 programs landed strong classes in what was a very, very good year for talent West of the Rockies. Oregon managed to flip several recruits, such as wide receiver Chance Allen from Oklahoma State and a terrific pick up in Bralon Addison from Texas A&M (who took a late visit and should fit perfectly in Chip Kelly's system). Though many were skeptical of the hire initially, Jim Mora grabbed a terrific class and fellow newcomers Rich Rodriguez and Mike Leach also had good first efforts. There really wasn't a "bad" class among the bunch and even lowly Colorado landed a top 100 player.

Texas being Texas

The Longhorns finished in a familiar spot right at the top of the class rankings and even though they couldn't push Alabama off the top spot, this has some major players who can play early and often. Malcom Brown is a beast at defensive tackle and Manny Diaz' defensive staff pulled one of the big surprises in taking Torshiro Davis away from LSU. The class has the top running back in the country with record-setter Johnathan Gray and the state's top wide out in Cayleb Jones. Mack Brown also closed very well, grabbing speedy Daje Johnson and linebackers Dalton Santos and Bryce Cottrell in addition to Davis. It will be a young Texas team in 2012 but with this class and the current roster, it will certainly be a talented one.

Category: NCAAF
Tags: Adolphus Washington, Al Golden, Alabama, Andrew Luck, Andrus Peat, Arik Armstead, Arizona State, Arkansas, Auburn, Avery Young, BCS, Big Ten, Bob Stoops, Bralon Addison, Brian Kelly, Bryce Cottrell, Cal, California, Cayleb Jones, Chance Allen, Chip Kelly, Chris Casher, Colorado, Cordarrelle Patterson, Daje Johnson, Dalton Santos, Dalvon Stuckey, Dante Fowler Jr., Darius Philon, Darreus Rogers, Dennis Erickson, Deontay Greenberry, Dillon Lee, Dorial Green-Beckham, Duke, Duke Johnson, Eddie Goldman, Edmund Ray, Florida, Florida State, Gary Pinkel, Georgia, Gunner Kiel, Houston, Ifeadi Odenigbo, Jabari Ruffin, Jamie Christian, Jim Mora, John Theus, Johnathan Gray, Jordan Payton, Jordan Simmons, Josh Garnett, Josh Harvey-Clemons, Justin Shanks, Justin Taylor, Keith Marshall, Kentucky, Korren Kirven, Kyle Murphy, Landon Collins, Lane Kiffin, Leonard Williams, LSU, Mack Brown, Malcom Brown, Malin Jones, Manny Diaz, Mario Edwards, Mark Stoops, Matt Lubick, Max Tuerk, Miami, Michael Floyd, Mike Leach, Missouri, NCAA, Nelson Agholor, Nick Saban, Noah Spence, Northwestern, Notre Dame, Ohio State, Oklahoma State, Oregon, P.J. Williams, Pac-12, Patrick Towles, Randy moss, Reggie Northrup, Reggie Ragland, Rich Rodriguez, Ronald Darby, Se'Von Pittman, SEC, Shaq Thompson, Signing Day Wrap, Stanford, T.J. Yeldon, Tee Shepard, Tennessee, Texas, Texas A&M, Thomas Johnson, Todd Gurley, Tommy Schutt, Tony Levine, Torshiro Davis, Tosh Lupoi, Tracy Howard, UCLA, Under Armour All-American Game, Urban Meyer, USC, Vanderbilt, Washington, Zach banner

Since: Nov 3, 2007
Posted on: February 6, 2012 1:56 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

I don't think Greenberry is Houston's highest rated recruit ever. I believe that was Lufkin HS defensive lineman T.J. Turner in 1982. He was Parade's top rated lineman that year and was in every top ten list. Great sign nonetheless.

Since: Aug 17, 2006
Posted on: February 6, 2012 1:23 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

I cant wait to play the Gators in 2013! Go Canes!

Since: Jan 2, 2012
Posted on: February 6, 2012 8:56 am

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

Couple of things that interest me about the article, first Mack Brown and Texas.  Does anyone wish that Texas would have a football season as their recruiting classes?  Don't get me wrong, they are a good football team, but every spring we hear how Texas wins a recruiting war, you think they should run away with the Big 12 and the nation.  The best underrated recruit to go with DGB of Mizzou was Maty Mauk out of Ohio, QB who was one of top HS passers in the country.  But he comes from a smaller school, but look for his name in a couple of years teaming up with DGB.  Of course recruiting is like the NFL Draft, some work and some don't.

Since: Jun 5, 2011
Posted on: February 5, 2012 4:16 pm

Saban shows his class

So, Saban "knew pretty much exactly what he was getting," and still had to renege late on a couple of offers to kids who had their hearts set on playing for him?  What a classy, classy man.  I can hear the Bammer faithful now: "that Nick Saban is a real Mother Teresa."  Or, "that kid didn't really want to play for Bama or he would have grayshirted."

Saban is apparently living proof that karma doesn't exist.  If it did, Saban would have fallen fast and hard by now.  Maybe it will make an appearance soon.

Since: May 24, 2010
Posted on: February 5, 2012 10:04 am

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

Hey Gamecock, I’ll toss you a mulligan for saying that Akili Smith played for Urban at Utah.  We all know you meant Alex but Akili says whatup, he is happy to have been mentioned since no one has thought of him for about 5 years.  The one thing the article said that resonates for me has to do with Mack Brown.  Think about it, what other coach doesn’t even have to recruit at all and still land top classes.  Kids going up inTexasdream of playing for UT so to suggest he is a great recruiter is a joke.  What rings true is that no matter how many 5 star prospects he gets and no matter how many Top 5 classes (on paper) come to him and want to play for UT, he still underachieves like none other!  I take that back, I always have seen him and Pete Carroll (when he was at USC) as guys who have loaded rosters but do less with more.  I have said that a few times and while I don’t hold unethical coaches in high regard I will say that Les, Nick and Urban seem to get their top classes to perform on the field and perform when it counts.

Since: Sep 5, 2006
Posted on: February 5, 2012 9:29 am

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

Yeh meyer has been know to drive the getaway car for his students.

Since: Jul 21, 2008
Posted on: February 4, 2012 2:36 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

No, the problem was he recruited Cam Newton to replace Tebow but Cam was asked to leave FL.  His fallback was Brantley.  Urban has left everywhere when his star QB leaves.  He left Bowling Green after two successful seasons because his QB graduated.  He left Utah after two seasons because Akili Smith was drafted into the NFL.  He left FL for medical reasons or was it really he did not have a star QB and could not handle just being succesful.  He needed to be dominant.  How much time did he spend with the family when he took another job that had him on TV all the time. 

He has a built in excuse.  I agree with you that if they are not winning that pesky health and spend time with family excuse will crop up again.  I do not dislike him and I am sympathetic to the reasons he provided.  However, I do not find him trustworthy on the topic. I agree with you.  Let's just wait and see.

Since: Oct 11, 2006
Posted on: February 2, 2012 10:10 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

UF recruits criminals! Most arrests by a long shot the last 5 years. Just type up most arrests college football program on Google & you'll see UF pop up like 3 times on the front page! Student athletes??!! Successful NFL career??!! Haha!! FSU has sent more players to the NFL than UF the last 25 years. Since 1988 Miami has sent 136 players to the NFL, FSU 125, UF 107.

Let me know when you go undefeated or play someone out of state out of conference. Haven't since 1990 vs. Syracuse & got crushed. At least LSU, Alabama, UGA, Tennessee etc. play on the road out of conference out of state.

Keep your players out of jail....that's the 1st step.

Since: May 9, 2009
Posted on: February 2, 2012 9:31 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

I can't believe I am agreeing with a Michigan fan but here I am...I agree Urban is a better recruiter...i.e., Florida, specifically Tim Tebow. The Gators went south after he left despite some stud athletes on that Florida team. Problem was he recruited Brantley to fit his system not the other way around and while they did finish on a high note beating Ohio State Charlie Weis and Will Muschamp were left with a pretty bare cupboard. So the new kid on the block especially following the scandal at Ohio State was just what the Bucs needed. Time will tell if he can still deliver and for Ohio State fans right now all they care about is beating your team. I dont dislike Urban Meyer; I just dont trust him. It was a convenient excuse with his medical situation - not saying not sympathetic - just saying and now he is all better and has a family contract that he signed which will prohibit him from overdoing it...Seriously? All that is is his ready made excuse should things not work out at Ohio State...just and see.

Since: May 9, 2009
Posted on: February 2, 2012 9:02 pm

Signing Day Coast-to-Coast Wrap

As a ND fan I was very disappointed he decided to go to Houston but good luck to him. I wont be like the LSU fans who railed on Notre Dame after Gunner Kiel decided to go to Notre Dame instead of LSU. Not even going to pretend the Irish took several hits losing several players to USC and Ohio State but did still manage to snag a few as well. I think whatever stars are attached to these athletes will be worthless if their talent isnt developed no matter where they decided to go. We all know sometimes these stud athletes just dont live up to the hype. Case in point for Notre Dame was Ron Powlus, the no 1 qb out of high school and Jimmy Clausen. I think JC was better than Powlus and it isnt his fault he was drafted by a team who drafted Cam Newton...Ditto with Brady Quinn playing behind Tim Tebow...tough for both guys. So time will tell just how good these guys are...Go Irish!

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or